• David Martin

What do Benjamin Franklin, TV Cops and an Old Business Adage Have in Common?

They all provide timely advice to prevent clients from being negatively impacted by accepting severance payments.

One of the harder choices an employee makes when terminating employment is whether to accept a severance payment which usually requires the signing of a release of all claims. That includes a release of all ERISA claims. (Warning: This can arise in the worker’s compensation context, and not just labor law claims.) If the individual has a pension or 401(k), is disabled and has an ongoing disability claim, or may need to file a disability claim, their claims could be impacted. Oral assurances may not help much in avoiding impact of those claims. Many employers will except the ERISA claims from the release that may be at stake, if timely requested. However, if that is refused, every employee needs to carefully weigh whether acceptance of the severance payment is adequate compensation. If the agreement is asserted as a defense, assuming the language of the release is adequate to guarantee, an employee win is not the best approach.

A recent case bears this out, Stephens v. Time Customer Serv., Inc., No. 8:17-CV-1338-T-33AEP, 2017 WL 6042109, at *1 (M.D. Fla. Dec. 6, 2017). Stephens sought ERISA benefits after signing her severance agreement. Eventually, she filed a Complaint against the Time Customer Service (TCS) Inc. Plan and Lescaille as Plan Administrator for denial of benefits, breach of fiduciary duty, and failure to respond to document requests. In response, a counterclaim was filed seeking to enforce the severance agreement. Stephens sought dismissal using the language in the severance agreement. The court noted that all entities and people associated with TCS Inc. were covered as intended third-party beneficiaries of the agreement, and that was a problem:

“Therefore, the TCS Plan and Lescaille have plausibly alleged that they can seek recoupment at least as third-party beneficiaries of the Agreement.”

Stephens, frustrated at this, asserted that the release's terms did not apply to her ERISA claims because “the release expressly provided that it does not constitute a waiver of Stephens' right to vested accrued benefits” or “of claims arising after the date the release was signed.” The court noted this might be true, but agreed with defendants that this argument is more appropriate for the summary judgment stage: “For now, the Amended Counterclaim plausibly alleges that Stephens' ERISA claims were waived under the release, and thus Stephens has breached the terms of the Plan.”

A word to the wise – carefully evaluate a severance agreement before your client signs it! Even if Stephens wins, there will be discovery and briefing, all at a significant cost.

#ERISAdisabilitylawyer #ERISA

Contact us today for a free initial consultation.

The Martin Law Group is dedicated to being your go-to ERISA attorneys and long term disability lawyers. Whether you are pursuing a long-term disability claim, life insurance benefits, or your pension or retirement benefits, we will meet with you face-to-face to discuss your claim at a location convenient for you. 


In an effort to make disability claims as easy as possible, we offer a free initial consultation. We often work with clients in Huntsville, Mobile, Birmingham, Montgomery, Dothan, Tuscaloosa, and Florence, in Alabama, as well as with clients in Columbus, Meridian, Jackson, Hattiesburg, Tupelo, and Gulfport, Mississippi, and surrounding areas.

Contact us today for a free consultation.

Long term disability attorney
Long term disability lawyer alabama

Tuscaloosa Office

2117 Jack Warner Pkwy
Suite #1
Tuscaloosa, Alabama 35401
Toll-Free: 800-284-9309
Local: 205-343-1771

Birmingham Office

The WSK Building
2323 2nd Avenue North
Birmingham, Alabama 35203
Toll-Free: 800-284-9309
Local: 205-343-1771
  • Long term disability lawyer
  • ERISA disability lawyer
  • Retirement benefits lawyer

© 2020 by The Martin Law Group, LLC

Sitemap | Legal Disclaimers | Privacy Policy

Website proudly created by Cartography Consulting.

DISCLAIMER: The information presented on this website should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship. Therefore, no information of any kind that you provide us before such a relationship is created is confidential or privileged.

Furthermore, no representation is made that the quality of the legal services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.