• David Martin

The Games Long Term Disability Insurers Play - Game #3: Do-Overs

Updated: Jun 18, 2019



I have been in a friendly golf game where the players agreed to three mulligans or do-overs per game. I’ve also played games with small children, and if they messed up, I allowed them a do-over. However, when it comes to long-term disability claim decisions, you are dealing with a serious matter—most often, impacting the financial survival of a long-term disability claimant. That is not a time to allow do-overs, or mulligans, and certainly not when only one side holds the privilege. Prudential Ins. Co. played the do-over game in its claims handling recently (See Paquin v. The Prudential Insurance Company of America, 2018 WL 3586397, D. Colo. July 26, 2018). Facts of the Case

  • Mr. Paquin contracted encephalitis from a mosquito carrying the West Nile virus. Brain damage and cognitive difficulties resulted.

  • He first claimed short-term disability and then long-term disability benefits, and Prudential paid them.

  • In fact, Prudential regularly reviewed the long-term disability claim and paid the benefit for 11 years.

  • After 11 years, Prudential—probably through an overaggressive adjuster—decided it needed to terminate the claim benefit.

  • It hired three doctors to provide the needed opinions to deny the claim. These doctors ignored 11 years of claims handling and 16 healthcare professionals in various fields who supported the claimant’s disability.

Prudential denied the claim and rejected the appeal as well, forcing Mr. Paquin to file a lawsuit. However, the court was not impressed with the game Prudential played. It noted:

The evidentiary scoreboard, if you will, reads as follows: 16 healthcare professionals (all doctors of medicine or neuropsychology, aside from one occupational therapist and one speech-language pathologist, including one doctor who was hired by Prudential) support a finding that Mr. Paquin is disabled; three doctors hired by Prudential found that Mr. Paquin is not disabled under the terms of the policy. In addition, per ERISA case law, the Court views the fact that Prudential paid Mr. Paquin LTD benefits for 11 years while conducting regular reviews as favorable to Mr. Paquin’s claim. As recently as February 2014 Prudential Claim Manager Mary Stratton noted in Mr. Paquin’s file that his cognitive issues were not likely to improve, and that there were no gainful employment options for Mr. Paquin based on the evidence in Prudential’s record.

Clearly the court was not impressed with the game of do-overs. Long-term disability insurers are not permitted to disregard years of claim decisions and then claim a do-over to string together some evidence to deny the claim. The challenge here is for a claimant to find an attorney with the experience needed to properly develop the claim during the claim process and familiarity with the law to press the case during litigation. ERISA is not fair, but we have seen this game played many times. It is nice to see a court make the right call. We can help if one of your clients encounters this game.

#LongtermdisabilitylawyerAlabama #LongtermdisabilitylawyerMississippi #longtermdisabilityinsurance #longtermdisability #longtermdisabilitylawyer

Contact us today for a free initial consultation.

The Martin Law Group is dedicated to being your go-to ERISA attorneys and long term disability lawyers. Whether you are pursuing a long-term disability claim, life insurance benefits, or your pension or retirement benefits, we will meet with you face-to-face to discuss your claim at a location convenient for you. 

 

In an effort to make disability claims as easy as possible, we offer a free initial consultation. We often work with clients in Huntsville, Mobile, Birmingham, Montgomery, Dothan, Tuscaloosa, and Florence, in Alabama, as well as with clients in Columbus, Meridian, Jackson, Hattiesburg, Tupelo, and Gulfport, Mississippi, and surrounding areas.

Contact us today for a free consultation.

800-284-9309

info@erisacase.com

Tuscaloosa Office

2117 Jack Warner Pkwy
Suite #1
Tuscaloosa, Alabama 35401
Toll-Free: 800-284-9309
Local: 205-343-1771

Birmingham Office

The WSK Building
2323 2nd Avenue North
Birmingham, Alabama 35203
Toll-Free: 800-284-9309
Local: 205-343-1771
  • Long term disability lawyer
  • ERISA disability lawyer
  • Retirement benefits lawyer

© 2020 by The Martin Law Group, LLC

Sitemap | Legal Disclaimers | Privacy Policy

Website proudly created by Cartography Consulting.

DISCLAIMER: These recoveries and testimonials are not an indication of future results. Every case is different, and regardless of what friends, family, or other individuals may say about what a case is worth, each case must be evaluated on its own facts and circumstances as they apply to the law. The valuation of a case depends on the facts, the injuries, the jurisdiction, the venue, the witnesses, the parties, and the testimony, among other factors. Furthermore, no representation is made that the quality of the legal services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.